Relative clauses help identify or describe a referent. Choose the relative form, punctuation and word order according to what the clause refers to and how it functions. This guide explains those choices with examples; adding a relative clause does not automatically make a sentence clearer.
A relative clause often modifies a noun phrase: in “The book that I borrowed was fascinating,” that I borrowed describes the book. It is a clause, not just a phrase without a verb. Relative clauses can also use where or when, and a supplementary which-clause can refer to an earlier proposition: “The meeting ended early, which surprised Jo.” Here which refers to the meeting’s ending early rather than only to the noun meeting.
Use the examples to check reference, clause type and punctuation. Several alternatives can be grammatical, with differences in register or meaning.
Defining and Non-Defining Relative Clauses
Understanding relative clauses begins with differentiating between defining and non-defining relative clauses. Both serve to give more information about a noun, but in distinct ways.
Defining relative clauses: These help identify or delimit the intended referent. Removing one may leave a grammatical sentence but change which people or things are meant. For example:
“The people who live next door are friendly.” Here, “who live next door” specifies which people we’re talking about.
Non-defining relative clauses: These add supplementary information about an already identified referent. In writing, set them off with commas; when the clause occurs in the middle of a sentence, use both opening and closing commas. Supplementary does not mean that the information is unimportant or that deleting it preserves the entire message.
“My English teacher, who is from Canada, has an interesting accent.” Who is from Canada adds a separate description of the teacher. Removing it leaves the main clause intact, but removes information about the teacher; it does not preserve every claim made in the original sentence.
Keeping these differences in mind will help you decide when to use defining or non-defining relative clauses for precise communication.
The Role of Relative Pronouns
Choose the relative form by reference and grammatical role, as well as clause type. Some forms have more than one role.
Who: Refers to people and can be a subject or object: “the woman who works here”; “the person who I called.” An object who is common outside very formal styles.
For example: “The woman who works here is very helpful.”
Whom: An object form referring to people, common in formal writing, especially after a fronted preposition: “the person to whom I wrote.” Who is also possible in many object-relative patterns when the preposition is left at the end.
For example: “The professor, whom the students admired, gave an inspiring lecture.”
Whose: Expresses a possessive relationship and can refer to things as well as people: “a building whose roof needs repair.”
For example: “That’s the author whose book you liked.”
Which: Can refer to animals or things in defining and non-defining clauses. Some style guides prefer that for defining clauses, but defining which is grammatical. Supplementary which may also refer to a preceding clause.
For example: “The car which I bought last year is already having issues.”
That: Can refer to people, animals, or things in defining relative clauses.
For example: “The house that Jack built is still standing.”
Omission of Relative Pronouns
In a defining relative clause, an object relative pronoun can often be omitted. Check the grammatical role and position of any preposition; this is not permission to remove every relative word.
For instance:
“The movie (that) we watched last night was amazing.”
In “The movie (that) we watched last night was amazing,” the movie is what we watched, and we is the relative-clause subject. That can be omitted in this defining object pattern.
Keep the subject relative pronoun in a full finite relative clause: “the man who called.” Removing who alone would leave “the man called” with a different possible structure or meaning. A reduced form, such as “the man standing at the door,” is another construction, not evidence that a subject word can always be dropped from an unchanged finite clause.
For example:
“The man who called you this morning is at the door.” (The pronoun “who” cannot be omitted as it acts as the subject.)
Relative Clauses in Different Contexts
Relative clauses are versatile and can be used in a variety of contexts to create more detailed and nuanced sentences. Here are some examples:
Formal writing: A relative clause can identify or describe a subject, but formality does not make an unsupported research claim valid. A hypothetical language model is:
“The report, which has two sections, describes the proposed method.” This illustrates a supplementary relative clause without inventing a completed study or claiming a breakthrough.
Everyday Conversation: In casual conversations, relative clauses help in keeping sentences clear and informative. For example:
“Do you know the girl who sits next to me in class?”
Storytelling: Relative clauses are excellent for adding detail to stories, making them more vivid and engaging. For example:
“Once upon a time, there was a brave knight who fought dragons.”
Choose a relative clause when it makes the reference or added information clear. A separate sentence may work better if the result becomes hard to follow.
Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them
When learning relative clauses, it’s easy to make mistakes that can confuse your intended meaning. Here are some common errors and tips on avoiding them:
Choosing forms: Identify whether the relative word is a subject, object or possessive form, and whether the clause is defining or supplementary.
Who is not limited to subject use; whom is an object form. Which can introduce defining or non-defining clauses about things, while that is used in defining clauses and does not replace who/which in a non-defining clause. In a non-defining clause, do not omit the relative pronoun.
Using Incorrect Punctuation: Forgetting commas in non-defining clauses can lead to confusion.
Compare “My brother who lives in New York is visiting” with “My brother, who lives in New York, is visiting.” The first uses the clause to identify the intended brother; the second presents New York as supplementary information about an already identified brother. The distinction may suggest a contrast in context, but punctuation alone does not prove how many brothers the speaker has.
Omission and prepositions: An object relative can be omitted in a defining clause with a stranded preposition, but not in the equivalent fronted-preposition pattern.
“The friend I went with” is already a valid defining noun phrase; it does not require who or whom. In a full sentence, “The friend I went with is here” is grammatical. “The friend who/whom I went with is here” is also possible. In the more formal fronted pattern, use “the friend with whom I went,” not “the friend with I went.”
Use a complete example and explain which alternatives fit. A pronoun’s presence or absence must be judged in its actual clause pattern.
Practice Makes Perfect
Practise by identifying the intended referent and the role of the relative word, then explain a permitted revision:
Writing exercise: Compare “The book that I borrowed is new” with “The book I borrowed is new.” Then explain why “The person who called is here” cannot simply lose who in the same intended full-relative structure.
Speaking Practices: Engage in conversations or storytelling exercises where you consciously use relative clauses. This can be done with a study partner or in language learning groups.
Quizzes and Worksheets: Many websites offer quizzes and worksheets focused on relative clauses. These can be excellent for testing your understanding and identifying areas for improvement.
Reading and Analysis: Read books, articles, or any written material and identify the relative clauses. Analyzing how professional writers use them can provide valuable insights.
Check your examples against the clause type, reference and intended meaning. Practice can reveal a specific point to revisit without establishing broad fluency.
Conclusion
To review a relative clause, ask what it refers to, which grammatical role the relative form has, and whether the information identifies the referent or supplements it.
When more than one form is possible, explain the difference in register or structure. Do not reject an object who, defining which or an omitted object relative merely because another option is more formal.
Keep the reader’s interpretation clear. Use commas for supplementary clauses, preserve necessary relative forms and prepositions, and choose a separate sentence when an added clause obscures the message.
Happy learning, and may your journey to mastering English grammar be both enjoyable and rewarding!
Grammar references
See Cambridge English Grammar Today on relative pronouns and defining and non-defining relative clauses.
